Showing posts with label Heresies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Heresies. Show all posts

Monday, December 13, 2010

Mary-is-God Heresy Part I by Bro. Marwil N. Llasos, O.P.

The Virgin Mary... Handmaiden of God


I had a chat with a lady from Cebu who claims to be following my blog The Knight of Mary (www.bromarwilnllasos.blospot.com). She paid me compliments for the work I am doing for the Lord, His Blessed Mother and the Church. At first, I did not know what her intention was. As I always accommodate all forms of communications to me and take the time to answer queries about the faith, I entertained her questions through chat and email. It was only after a series of exchanges did I realize that she is into a group that exalts Mary as a goddess, the incarnation of Wisdom (which to her is the Holy Spirit) and the “divine feminine.”

I was aghast to know that she believes in downright heresy. It is lunacy to ever think that Mary is a goddess! No sane Catholic would ever think that way. The Church, in her more than 2000-year history, has never taught the Blessed Virgin Mary to be divine. Though exalted by grace, Mary remains to be a human being. Mary’s humanity is the guaranty of the true humanity of Christ who took flesh from her.

The lady later on identified herself to me as Elizabeth R. Halican of No. 14 Holy Family Village I, Banilad, Cebu. She is adamant in her belief that Mary is the divine feminine, the personification or the incarnation of the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit, to Ms. Halican, is the Old Testament Wisdom. This is rank heresy.

In my recent email to Ms. Halican, I told her that I will respond to her concerns publicly through my blog. So here it is. This is the first in a series of articles that will critique the heretical (and obviously crazy) doctrine that Mary is God.

In an email to me last 12 December 2010, Elizabeth R. Halican complained against my calling her views heretical. I was merely stating a fact – and restating the pronouncement of Church authorities.

In February 2009, Ricardo Cardinal Vidal, then Archbishop of Cebu, warned all the Catholic faithful “to guard against the teachings of a religious organization that reportedly elevates Mary as the third person of the Holy Trinity.” The Cardinal exhorted the faithful to “beware of this group” and further said that the group commits the doctrinal error of defining the Holy Trinity as the “Father, the Son and the Mother,” with Mary taking the place of the Holy Spirit. This is precisely the heretical doctrine that Ms. Halican believes and promotes.

The Archbishop of Cebu said that that “if a Catholic indulges oneself in believing DEO's idea, he or she will be unable to receive the sacraments of the church.” Hence, Ms. Halican cannot receive the sacraments of the church. That is to say, she (along with the adherents of this pernicious heresy) is no longer a Catholic in good standing.

Cardinal Vidal expressed the hope that our “devotion to Mary will be based on the sound doctrine of the one, holy, apostolic and Catholic Church.” He reminded us that “Mary is the same young woman of Nazareth, who obeyed God's will in delivering Jesus into the world and taking good care of God's beloved until His death on the cross.”

It is not yet too late for Ms. Elizabeth R. Halican and others like her situated to repent and abjure their heresy. As the good Cardinal Vidal himself said, “Let's not be ashamed to confess our sins because although our sins are big, God will forgive us as He is merciful.” He added, “Mary is always praying that we may repent from our sinful ways.”

Reference:

Ador Vincent Mayol, Guard against group’s heresy – Vidalhttp://globalnation.inquirer.net/cebudailynews/news/view/20090223-190538/Guard-against-groups-heresy--Vidal>

Saturday, October 9, 2010

SIMPLE QESTION AND ANSWER ON CHRISTOLOGICAL HERESIES

Byzantine icon of Christ in Mount Athos


Regina said...

Question lang po Padre. When and what heretical movement first questioned the divinity of our Lord Jesus Christ? Was it Docetism in the 1st century of Arianism in the 4th century?



Fr. Abe, CRS said...

Dear Regina,




The First Heresy to deny categorically the Divinity of Jesus is EBIONISM founded by Ebion. This is a group of heretical Jews who taught that the Lord Jesus is fully human and not Divine. However,they failed to convince the believers. The one who truly propagated the denial of the Divinity of Jesus is Arius of Alexandria. He succeeded in converting many places to his heresies but St. Athanasius and the succeeding Fathers of the Church successfully defeated this group.




Docetism is a heresy that teaches Jesus is only God but not human.




Then, Apollinarianism teaches that Jesus is God but not fully human because it teaches that the spirit of Jesus is replaced by the Divine Spirit. Thus Jesus had a body and soul but no human spirit.


REFUTING THE CLAIM THAT THE EARLY CHRISTIANS ARE DIVIDED INTO FOUR SECTS: EBIONISM, MARCIONISM, PROTO-ORTHODOX AND GNOSTICISM

Christ as the All-Powerful Lord of the Universe - The Alpha and the Omega


Anonymous said...

the 4 christian groups Ebionite, Proto Orthodox, Marcionite & Gnostic....




i think Ebionites is the first christian.. why because they are Jews like Jesus... i think they are the original follower of Jesus..



Fr. Abe, CRS said...

O COMMON. THE REASON WHY THEY ARE CALLED EBIONITES BECAUSE THE FOUNDER IS A CERTAIN EBION. HA, HA, HA...




THE FIRST CHRISTIANS ARE JEWS BUT CATHOLICS NOT EBIONITES. HA, HA, HA... THAT IS WHAT YOU THINK. UNFORTUNATELY FOR YOU THIS GROUP DIED OUT BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT THE TRUE CHRISTIANS. IF THEY ARE THE TRUE CHRISTIANS THEN THEY WOULD HAVE SURVIVED AND THE CATHOLIC CHURCH WOULD DISAPPEAR.




SAME FOR MARCIONITES. THIS IS NOT CHRISTIAN BECAUSE IT REJECTS THE OLD TESTAMENT AND DENIES THAT JESUS IS THE SON OF THE GOD OF THE OLD TESTAMENT. THIS IS FOUNDED IN ROME BY MARCION IN 144AD.




THAT PROTO ORTHODOX IS A LATEST INVENTION. THERE IS NO SUCH THING IN THE EARLY CHURCH. THE CHURCH THEN IS CALLED CATHOLIC. HERE IS THE MAN WHO INVENTED THAT CONCEPT THAT YOU IGNORANTLY UPHELD:




"Proto-orthodox Christianity is a term, coined by New Testament scholar Bart D. Ehrman, used to describe the Early Christian movement which was the precursor of Christian orthodoxy. Ehrman argues that this group, which became prominent by the end of the third century" [WIKIPEDIA]




THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS EARLY CHRISTIAN MOVEMENT BUT THERE WAS ONLY THE ONE AND ONLY CHURCH FOUNDED BY JESUS ON PETER THE APOSTLE.




GNOSTICISM, LIKE EBIONISM AND MARCIONISM, WAS AN ENEMY OF CHRISTIANITY. IT IS SYNCRETISTIC. IT MEANS IT IS A COMBINATION OF MANY BELIEF SYSTEM. IT COMBINES SOME CHRISTIAN TEACHINGS WITH THAT OF THE PAGANS AND OF THE ANCIENT PHILOSOPHERS SUCH AS PLATO. IT IS ALSO DUALISTIC. IT TEACHES THAT THERE ARE TWO GODS: ONE GOOD AND ONE EVIL. HOW CAN THAT BE CHRISTIAN?




DON'T INCLUDE US IN YOUR HALLUCINATIONS.