BAGONG PAKIKIPAGTALASTASAN HINGGIL SA 'SOLA SCRIPTURA' O 'BIBLE ALONE' DOCTRINE, Part 4

The Apostles preaching the Gospel... orally for years.

Kenston said...

Naniniwala po ako sa Sola Scriptura... It does not mean abolishing traditions, instead, traditions should not contradict what is written in the Scriptures.

Kaya ok lng po kung may mga traditions, prang Filipino traditions ng pagmamano, ok lang yun, kasi di yun nagcocontradict sa nakasulat sa Bible na honor your father and mother... ang problema po kasi yung mga tradition na kumokontra sa nakasulat sa Bible... to find some verses to justify a tradition is not sufficient (bka kasi taking out of context lng) but you have to check if it contradicts other verses. Basahin niyo na lamang ito: http://www.gotquestions.org/sola-scriptura.html mas mauunawaan niyo po... direct naman po yung mga explanations dun sa site na yun e :)

January 10, 2011 10:21 AM

Fr. Abe, CRS said...

Dear Kenston,

[Naniniwala po ako sa Sola Scriptura...]

IBIG SABIHIN SINASALANGSANG MO ANG BIBLIA. KASI HINDI TINUTURO NG BIBLIA ANG SOLA SCRIPTURA.

[It does not mean abolishing traditions, instead, traditions should not contradict what is written in the Scriptures.]

IF YOU TRULY BELIEVE THAT THERE ARE THE TRADITIONS AND THAT THESE TRADITIONS ARE NOT CONTRADICTING THE BIBLE THEN YOU ARE ALREADY A CATHOLIC. HE, HE, HE... YOU ARE UPHOLDING THE CATHOLIC POSITION. THAT IS WHY WE ARE CORRECT IN SAYING THAT THE BIBLE AND THE SACRED TRADITIONS MUST GO HAND IN HAND. BOTH ARE IMPORTANT AND THEY DO NOT CONTRADICT EACH OTHER.

NOW, IF YOU UPHELD TRADITIONS THEN IT MEANS SOLA SCRIPTURA IS WRONG. THE FORMULA 'BIBLE ALONE' IS AN ABSOLUTE REJECTION OF APOSTOLIC TRADITIONS.

YOUR POSITION, KENSTON, IS CONTRADICTORY AND ILLOGICAL. IT DOES NOT JIBE WITH REALITY.

[Kaya ok lng po kung may mga traditions, prang Filipino traditions ng pagmamano, ok lang yun, kasi di yun nagcocontradict sa nakasulat sa Bible na honor your father and mother...]

KUNG OK ANG TRADITIONS THEN PALPAK ANG SOLA SCRIPTURA. KAYA NGA BIBLE ALONE E, IT REJECTS EVERYTHING OUTSIDE THE BIBLE.

NOW TO CORRECT YOU. ANG PAGMAMANO AY HINDI PART OF ORAL OR SACRED OR APOSTOLIC TRADITION OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH. THAT IS JUST A CULTURAL EXPRESSION OF LOVE OF PARENTS. HINDI NGA IYAN SALUNGAT SA BIBLIA NA NAGSASABI NG HONOR YOUR FATHER AND YOUR MOTHER. PERO, HINDI IYAN ARAL NA GALING SA MGA APOSTOLES.

[ang problema po kasi yung mga tradition na kumokontra sa nakasulat sa Bible...]

WALA KAMING TRADITION NA KUMUKONTRA SA BIBLIA. KUNG GUSTO MONG PATUNAYAN YAN E MAGBIGAY KA NG HALIMBAWA.

YUNG PAGMAMANO AY HINDI DOCTRINA NG IGLESIA CATOLICA IBIG SABIHIN HINDI IYAN APOSTOLIC TRADITION. YAN AY FILIPINO CUSTOM... TRADITION OF MEN, GOOD TRADITION OF MAN NGA LANG.

IT SHOWS NA MABABAW ANG PAGKAKAINTINDI MO SA APOSTOLIC TRADITION.

[to find some verses to justify a tradition is not sufficient (bka kasi taking out of context lng) but you have to check if it contradicts other verses.]

HINDI NAMIN UGALI NA GUMAMIT LANG NG VERSES TO JUSTIFY NEWLY INVENTED DOCTRINES GAYA NG GINAGAWA NG MGA BORN AGAIN, BAPTISTS, PROTESTANTS, EVANGELICALS, INC, ADD AT IBA PA. WAG MO KAMING ITULAD SA INYO. ANG AMING MGA DOCTRINA AY ARAL NA NAMIN SINAUNA PA.

[Basahin niyo na lamang ito: http://www.gotquestions.org/sola-scriptura.html mas mauunawaan niyo po... direct naman po yung mga explanations dun sa site na yun e :)]

NAUUNAWAAN NAMIN ANG SOLA SCRIPTURA. OBVIOUS NAMAN ANG MEANING NG BIBLE ALONE E. NGAYON, KUNG SINASABI MO NA YOU ALSO ACCEPT TRADITIONS NA COMPATIBLE WITH THE BIBLE THEN WINAWASAK MO NA ANG SOLA SCRIPTURA. KASI BIBLE + TRADITIONS KA NA.

January 10, 2011 11:43 AM